June 10, 2021

Mafia III: Definite Edition (Steam) Review

This post may contain affiliate links from places like Amazon and Green Man Gaming, and we may earn a small commission when you click these links. All earnings will go to keeping this website as minimally ad-free as possible. 

Mafia III: Definite Edition (Steam) Review

By Joel | June 10, 2021
Mafia III boast stunning visuals, and nostalgic soundtrack but can't shoot its way out of a backdrop of repetitive gameplay and technical hiccups.

When Expectations Don't Hit the Mark.

Welcome to New Bordeaux, where the bourbon flows like water and the revenge plots are as thick as the bayou mud. Mafia III: Definitive Edition invites you to step into the gator-skin boots of Lincoln Clay, a Vietnam vet with a chip on his shoulder and a score to settle. If you're expecting another romp through the golden age of organized crime, prepare to have your fedora knocked off – this ain't your nonno's Mafia game.

Mafia III boast stunning visuals, and nostalgic soundtrack but can't shoot its way out of a backdrop of repetitive gameplay and technical hiccups.

A Tale of Betrayal and Familiar Faces

Let's start with the good stuff, shall we? The story in Mafia III is grittier than a po' boy sandwich dropped on Bourbon Street. It's a tale of betrayal, revenge, and power that would make Don Corleone nod in approval. The narrative weaves seamlessly between past and present, with documentary-style cutscenes that add depth and context to Lincoln's bloody crusade. And speaking of familiar faces, fans of the series will be tickled to see some old friends (and enemies) make appearances, tying this new chapter to the Mafia saga we know and love.

The setting of New Bordeaux, a fictionalized New Orleans, is a character in itself. From the neon-lit French Quarter to the misty bayous, every corner of this world oozes atmosphere. And let's not forget the soundtrack – a collection of 1960s hits so good, you'll find yourself cruising around just to finish listening to "Paint It Black" for the umpteenth time. Visually, the game is a treat, with stunning graphics that bring the era to life. The cutscenes, in particular, are so well-crafted you might forget you're not watching a Martin Scorsese flick.

However, not everything in New Bordeaux is as sweet as praline. The gameplay loop is more repetitive than a broken record at a sock hop. You'll find yourself clearing districts, assigning underbosses, and rinse-repeating until you can recite the mission structure in your sleep. It's like groundhog day, but with more explosions and fewer Bill Murrays.

Mafia III boast stunning visuals, and nostalgic soundtrack but can't shoot its way out of a backdrop of repetitive gameplay and technical hiccups.

The Good, the Bad, and the Buggy

Speaking of explosions, the game's optimization is about as stable as a house of cards in a hurricane. Even with a graphics card powerful enough to launch a rocket, you might find yourself dealing with more stutters than a nervous teenager asking for a prom date. And let's not forget the bugs and glitches – they're as common as beads at Mardi Gras and about as welcome as a hangover the morning after.

Side quests abound, but many feel as disconnected from the main story as a jazz improvisation from its original melody. You'll meet more characters than you can shake a voodoo doll at, but many contribute about as much to the plot as a random extra in a crowd scene. And for a game about organized crime, the damage modeling on vehicles is surprisingly disorganized as your car can take more punishment than a crash test dummy at a monster truck event.

Mafia III boast stunning visuals, and nostalgic soundtrack but can't shoot its way out of a backdrop of repetitive gameplay and technical hiccups.

Make Me an Offer That I Can Refuse

When considering buying the game, just remember that Mafia III: Definitive Edition is like a jazz fusion album—it's got some great riffs, but it doesn't quite live up to the classics that came before it. Given the stellar reputation of its predecessors, the expectations, I suppose, were higher than a cat on a hot tin roof.

However, if you can look past its flaws and embrace its unique flavor, you might enjoy this tumultuous tour through the criminal underworld of the 1960s. Just don't expect to be made an offer you can't refuse, because this time, it's more of a suggestion you might want to possibly consider.

Pros

  • Engaging Storyline: A gripping narrative that combines revenge and betrayal, reminiscent of classic crime films.
  • Familiar Faces: Characters from Mafia I and II make appearances, adding depth for long-time fans.
  • Atmospheric Setting: The vibrant world of New Bordeaux is beautifully crafted, capturing the essence of 1960s New Orleans.
  • Incredible Soundtrack: A fantastic selection of 1960s music that enhances the immersive experience.
  • Stunning Graphics and Cutscenes: Visually impressive with cinematic cutscenes that draw you into the story.

Cons

  • Repetitive Gameplay: Mission structures can feel monotonous, leading to a sense of déjà vu.
  • Bugs and Glitches: Technical issues can disrupt gameplay, detracting from the overall experience.
  • Excessive Side Quests: Many side missions feel disconnected from the main storyline, leading to filler content.
  • Overabundance of Characters: Too many characters can clutter the narrative without adding significant value to the plot.
  • Poor Optimization: Performance issues may arise even on high-end systems, affecting gameplay fluidity.
  • Limited Damage Modeling: Vehicle damage lacks realism, making crashes feel less impactful.

September 1, 2026
eBaseball Pro Spirit 2026 Spirits Mode: The Card Game That Builds Your Best Player

Spirits mode turns player creation into a poker game, and it is the fastest way to build an elite prospect. Which hands to chase, when to Double Up, and the point totals you need for a top rated player.

Read More
August 31, 2026
Planet of Lana Review: A Calm, Charming Adventure That Sneaks Up on You

A reader gifted me Planet of Lana, and I am glad they did. Our review of Wishfully's calm, gorgeous puzzle adventure: emotion over action, Studio Ghibli beauty, and why it earns a 4 out of 5.

Read More
August 26, 2026
Theropods Review: A Wordless Caveman Adventure That Talks With Its Hands

Theropods says nothing and means everything. A wordless caveman adventure that tells its whole story through gesture, grunts, and gorgeous pixel art.

Read More

POPULAR POSTS

November 29, 2021
'Second Extinction' Pre-Season 7 Out Now

Season 7 of the Co-op Dino Shooter Second Extinction Is Now Available on Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One & PC

November 15, 2019
The Takeover PC Review - Taking Back the Streets Sinch 80s

The Takeover does provide enough charm, action, and thumb numbing action to keep you fighting until Street of Rage 4 is released.

August 17, 2023
Dusty Rhodes: Wrestling's Maverick Hero or Narcissistic Villain?

Dive into the world of Dusty Rhodes, a man celebrated as wrestling's 'American Dream' and criticized for his narcissistic tendencies. Which side are you in?

July 16, 2023
Nintendo's Hilarious Plea: Don't Mess with the Game Card Slot on Your Nintendo Switch!

Clean Freaks Beware! Don't Let Cleaning Be the Game Over for Your Switch's Card Slot!

October 5, 2023
October Fright: The Behind-The-Scenes Madness of 'Jeepers Creepers 2

Dive into the backdrop of the iconic horror flick, Jeepers Creepers 2. Discover the camaraderie, antics, and challenges faced by the cast behind the camera.

envelope
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram