May 6, 2023

The Great Cartridge Debate: Why Nintendo Stuck with Cartridges and Paid the Price

This post may contain affiliate links from places like Amazon and Green Man Gaming — and we may earn a small commission when you click these links. All earnings will go to keeping this website as minimally ad-free as possible. Learn more here.

The Great Cartridge Debate: Why Nintendo Stuck with Cartridges and Paid the Price

By Nick | May 6, 2023

In the 1990s, gaming consoles were in the middle of a technological revolution - CD-based games were fast becoming the norm. But Nintendo, the gaming giant, had other ideas. While the rest of the industry moved to CDs, Nintendo stuck with their tried and true cartridges for their Nintendo 64. This decision puzzled many gamers and industry experts. But there were reasons behind this choice, and we'll explore them in this post.

The Great Cartridge Debate: Why Nintendo Stuck with Cartridges and Paid the Price

More Speed But Less Data

The argument for Nintendo's use of cartridges was two-fold. First, cartridges were faster than CD-ROMs. Loading times were much quicker, and cartridges allowed for more immediate data transfer, which was especially important for fast-paced games. This meant less waiting and more gameplay. Secondly, cartridges were much cheaper to produce than CDs - a crucial factor that helped Nintendo sell its console at a more reasonable price.

However, there were downsides to cartridges. While they were faster than CD's, they could not hold as much data as CDs. This led to limitations in the size and content of games. Moreover, the cost issue became significant as games became more complex and required larger cartridges which ultimately led to higher production costs.

But it was not just about technical specs and costs either, as there was an emotional aspect to it as well. Cartridges had been the backbone of the gaming industry since the beginning. For veterans and loyal gamers alike, cartridge-based games, with their iconic plastic casings and unique artwork, held a special place in their hearts. Nintendo recognized this sentiment and sought to leverage it in their favor.

Nintendo's decision to stick with cartridges came at a price, however. Third-party developers were not too happy with the limitations of cartridges, and many of them chose to develop games for Sony's PlayStation, which was entirely CD-based. This led to a loss of many great games that could have been on the Nintendo 64. Moreover, the limitations of cartridges, especially the storage limitations, meant that Nintendo struggled to adapt to the newer, more sophisticated games being released on other platforms.

CD or Not CD

While the choice to stick with cartridges may seem misguided in hindsight, it made perfect sense for Nintendo. The faster load times, lower production costs, and nostalgia factor made them a viable option at the time. However, as the industry advanced and games became more sophisticated, the limitations of cartridges began to hinder Nintendo's growth.

Though they succeeded with the Nintendo 64, the console ultimately fell short compared to its competitors, whose more excellent storage and capabilities were far more impressive. Regardless, the cartridge-based era of gaming holds a special place in our hearts, and as we look back, we are reminded of Nintendo's decision to stick to what they knew best.

January 12, 2024
Why the Iowa Caucus Matters: A Look at the First Crucial Step in the GOP Presidential Race

Understand the unique caucus process in Iowa and discover why this state sets the presidential race's pace.

Read More
January 11, 2024
A Sobering Look into the Trenches of Medical Management: War Hospital (Steam) Review

Experience the gritty reality of WW1 field hospitals in War Hospital and explores the game's immersive environment and powerful narrative.

Read More
January 10, 2024
Stay Hydrated and Game On: The Top Gaming Water Bottles for Endurance and Performance

Discover the ultimate gaming water bottles designed to keep you hydrated and at peak performance.

Read More


April 10, 2021
8 Things You Probably Didn't Know About Street Fighter

So, you think you're a Street Fighter expert, huh? But do you know the behind the scenes facts? I bet you didn't.

March 15, 2023
I'd Rather Be a Hammer Than A Nail: Fun Facts About Thor's Hammer

Learn about Thor's hammer, the mighty Mjölnir, and, uncover its history, power, and mysterious secrets.

October 5, 2021
Feeling Blue? Let Little Billy Add Some Color to Your Day

Rainbow Billy is a hopepunk, universal coming-of-age story that explores relatable themes like empathy, compassion, inclusion, and self-identity”

August 23, 2023
When Philips Tried to CD-Future: The CD-I Chronicles

Philips CD-I began as a bold fusion of gaming and interactive media, but a combination of high costs and lackluster game support saw it fade into obscurity.

November 16, 2022
Get 40% Off Open World FPS, Deadside, Until 11/27

Tired of your other survival games? Step up to Deadside, it's the real deal.

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram